8 Simple Ways to Tell if Pearls are Real or Fake: Expert Tips

8 Simple Ways to Tell if Pearls are Real or Fake: Expert Tips

Onki Mak

How do I know if these pearls are real? 

Pearls are beautiful gems that have captivated people for centuries. But with so many fake pearls out there, how can you tell if the ones you're looking at are real and not dyed pearls? This guide will show you some easy ways to spot genuine pearls, whether you're shopping for jewelry or just curious about a piece you already own. Understanding the characteristics of authentic pearls can help you make informed decisions and appreciate these oceanic treasures even more.

Key Takeaways: Identifying Authentic Pearls

  • Look for slight imperfections on the surface
  • Check for a natural shine and depth of color
  • Feel the weight and temperature of the pearl
  • Notice differences in size and shape
  • Consider getting a professional opinion for valuable pieces
  • Examine the pearl's luster and overtones
  • Perform the tooth test carefully
  • Compare the pearl's weight to known authentic pearls

    Understanding How Pearls Form

    Pearls are created when a tiny irritant, like a grain of sand, gets inside an oyster or mussel. To protect itself, the mollusk covers the irritant with layers of a substance called nacre. Over time, these layers build up to form a pearl. This process can take several years, which contributes to the rarity and value of natural pearls.

    There are two main types of pearls you'll find in jewelry:

    • Natural pearls: These are very rare and form without any human help in wild oysters. They are incredibly valuable due to their scarcity and the unpredictable nature of their formation.
    • Cultured pearls: These are much more common and are made by putting an irritant into an oyster on purpose. While still valuable, cultured pearls are more accessible and come in a wider variety of sizes, shapes, and colors.

    Both types are real pearls, but cultured pearls are what you'll usually see in stores. The cultivation process allows for more control over the pearl's development, resulting in a higher yield of jewelry-quality pearls. Check out our collection of genuine pearl jewelry to see some beautiful examples of cultured pearls in various styles and designs.

    Timeless Pink Pearl EleganceElegant Freshwater Pearl Necklace


    Visual Clues: What Real Pearls Look Like

    1. Surface Texture

    Real pearls aren't perfectly smooth. If you look closely, you should see tiny bumps and ridges on the surface. These little imperfections are actually a good sign! Fake pearls often look too perfect and smooth. The surface of a genuine pearl will have subtle variations that can be seen under magnification, resembling a series of overlapping platelets. This unique texture is a result of the natural layering process of nacre deposition.

    2. Luster and Shine

    Genuine pearls have a special kind of shine called luster. It's a deep, glowing shine that seems to come from inside the pearl, a characteristic that can help you tell if a pearl is real or fake. Fake pearls might be shiny, but their shine often looks more like it's just on the surface, like plastic. The luster of a real pearl is often described as soft and silky, with a subtle glow that appears to come from within. This unique optical effect is due to the way light interacts with the layers of nacre, creating a sense of depth that's hard to copy in fake pearls.

    Seraphine Pearl Elegance NecklaceSeraphine Pearl Elegance Necklace Detail

    Our Seraphine Pearl Elegance Necklace is a great example of the natural luster of real pearls. Notice how the light seems to dance on the surface of each pearl, creating a mesmerizing play of reflections that change as you move the necklace.

    3. Color and Overtones

    Real pearls often have subtle color changes when you look at them from different angles. This is called an overtone. For example, a white pearl might have a pink or green overtone. Fake pearls usually have a flat, single color. The complexity of color in genuine pearls is due to the layered structure of nacre, which can refract light in various ways. High-quality pearls may display multiple overtones, adding to their beauty and value. Some rare pearls, like Tahitian black pearls, can exhibit a stunning array of colors including peacock green, aubergine, and silver, making it important to understand their natural and cultured varieties.

    Hands-On Tests: Feel the Difference

    1. The Tooth Test

    Gently rub the pearl against your front teeth. Real pearls will feel slightly gritty or sandy, while fake pearls will feel smooth. Be careful not to scratch the pearl! This grittiness is due to the tiny ridges on the pearl's surface. However, it's important to note that this test should be done very gently, as rubbing too hard can damage the pearl's surface. Also, keep in mind that some high-quality fake pearls may also feel slightly gritty, so this test should not be relied upon by itself.

    2. Temperature Test

    Hold the pearl in your hand for about 30 seconds. Real pearls will feel cool at first but quickly warm up to your body temperature. Fake pearls often stay at room temperature or warm up more slowly. This is because pearls are good conductors of heat, while many materials used in fake pearls are not. However, be aware that some high-end fake pearls may be designed to mimic this property, so it's best to use this test along with other methods of checking.

    3. Weight Test

    Real pearls are usually heavier than fake ones of the same size. If you have a known real pearl, try comparing its weight to the one you're testing. This difference in weight is due to the density of nacre compared to materials used in fake pearls. However, this test can be tricky without proper equipment, as the difference may be subtle. For a more accurate check, jewelers often use special scales to measure the specific gravity of pearls, which can provide a more definitive indication of their authenticity.

    Ocean's Serenade Blue Pearl NecklaceElegant Freshwater Pearl Necklace

    Our Ocean's Serenade Blue Pearl Necklace and Elegant Freshwater Pearl Necklace both feature genuine pearls that pass these hands-on tests with flying colors. Each pearl in these necklaces has been carefully selected for its quality and authenticity, ensuring that you're getting a truly remarkable piece of jewelry.

    Looking Closer: What Experts Check

    1. Magnified Surface

    Using a magnifying glass or jeweler's loupe, experts can see the tiny ridges and patterns on a real pearl's surface. These patterns look a bit like overlapping plates or scales. This microscopic texture is a result of the way nacre is deposited in layers as the pearl forms. Fake pearls, even high-quality ones, typically lack this natural, organic surface structure. Experts may also look for tiny imperfections or variations in the surface, which are characteristic of natural growth processes.

    2. Drill Holes

    If the pearl is part of a necklace or other jewelry, the hole where it's strung can tell you a lot. Real pearls usually have drill holes with sharp edges, while fake pearls might have rough or chipped edges around the hole. The interior of the drill hole in a real pearl should show the concentric layers of nacre. In some cases, experts might even examine the drill hole under magnification to assess the quality and thickness of the nacre layers, which can indicate the pearl's overall quality and value.

    3. X-Ray Tests

    This is something only professionals can do, but it's a sure way to tell real from fake. Real pearls show up as having layers in an X-ray, while fake ones look solid. The X-ray reveals the internal structure of the pearl, including the nucleus (if it's a cultured pearl) and the layers of nacre surrounding it, which can help identify real pearls. This test can also help determine if a pearl is natural or cultured, as natural pearls will show concentric rings from the center outward, while cultured pearls typically have a larger, more distinct nucleus. X-ray testing is particularly valuable for assessing very high-value pearls or antique pieces where non-invasive authentication is crucial.

    Blooming Plumeria Black Pearl PendantBlooming Plumeria Black Pearl Pendant Detail

    Our Blooming Plumeria Black Pearl Pendant showcases a genuine Tahitian black pearl. These rare pearls are known for their unique colors and are always authenticated by experts. Tahitian pearls undergo rigorous testing to ensure their authenticity and quality, including X-ray examinations to verify their internal structure and nacre thickness.

    Different Types of Real Pearls

    1. Freshwater Pearls

    These are the most common type of cultured pearls. They come in many colors and shapes and are often more affordable than other types. Freshwater pearls are primarily produced in China and are known for their variety in size, shape, and color. They can range from tiny seed pearls to large baroque shapes, and their colors can include white, cream, yellow, lavender, and even peacock green. Freshwater pearls often have a softer luster compared to saltwater pearls but can still be quite beautiful and versatile in jewelry design.

    2. Akoya Pearls

    These saltwater pearls are known for being very round and having a high shine. They're often white or cream-colored. Akoya pearls are primarily cultured in Japan and China and are prized for their perfectly spherical shape and intense luster. They typically range from 2mm to 10mm in size, with the larger sizes being quite rare and valuable. Akoya pearls are often considered the classic pearl for traditional jewelry pieces like strands and stud earrings.

    3. South Sea Pearls

    These are some of the largest and most valuable pearls. They can be white, cream, or golden. South Sea pearls are cultured in the waters of Australia, Indonesia, and the Philippines. They are known for their large size, typically ranging from 8mm to 20mm, with some exceptional specimens even larger. The golden variety, produced by the gold-lipped oyster, is particularly prized for its rarity and unique color. South Sea pearls often have a soft, satiny luster and are frequently used in high-end jewelry designs.

    4. Tahitian Pearls

    Also known as black pearls, these come in dark colors like black, gray, and green, and it’s important to understand their authenticity. Tahitian pearls are cultured in French Polynesia and are famous for their exotic dark colors. Despite being called "black pearls," they actually come in a range of dark hues including peacock green, aubergine, and silver. These pearls are typically larger than Akoya pearls but smaller than South Sea pearls, ranging from 8mm to 14mm on average. Tahitian pearls are highly valued for their unique colors and often feature stunning overtones that shift in different lighting conditions.

    Peacock Pearl Enchantment BraceletPeacock Pearl Enchantment Bracelet Detail

    Our Peacock Pearl Enchantment Bracelet features beautiful freshwater pearls in unique colors, showcasing the variety available in real pearls and how to identify real ones. This bracelet demonstrates the wide range of colors and shapes that can be found in freshwater pearls, making it a versatile and eye-catching piece of jewelry.

    Common Fake Pearl Materials

    1. Glass Beads

    These are coated with a pearly substance to look like real pearls. They're often very smooth and uniform. Glass bead imitation pearls are typically made by dipping a glass bead into a solution containing fish scales or other iridescent materials. This coating gives them a pearl-like appearance, but they lack the depth and complexity of real pearls. Glass bead pearls are usually heavier than plastic imitations but lighter than genuine pearls of the same size.

    2. Plastic

    Plastic pearls are lightweight and can look very perfect and identical. They are often made from materials like acrylic or ABS plastic and are coated with a pearlescent finish. Plastic imitation pearls are typically very lightweight, which can be a giveaway when compared to real pearls. They also tend to have a more artificial sheen and lack the depth of luster seen in genuine pearls. However, some high-end plastic imitations can be quite convincing at first glance.

    3. Shell Pearls

    These are made from the inner layer of oyster shells, ground up and formed into beads. They can look quite real but lack the depth of genuine pearls. Shell pearls are created by coating a bead made of crushed shells with a nacre-like substance. While they can closely resemble real pearls in appearance, they typically have a more uniform surface and lack the subtle imperfections of genuine pearls. Shell pearls can be quite convincing and are sometimes marketed as a more affordable alternative to real pearls, but they don't have the same value or longevity as genuine pearls.

    Caring for Your Real Pearls

    Once you know you have real pearls, it's important to take good care of them. Proper care will ensure that your pearls maintain their luster and beauty for generations. Here are some essential tips:

    • Put your pearls on last when getting dressed and take them off first when you get home. This prevents exposure to hairsprays, perfumes, and other cosmetics that can damage the pearls.
    • Wipe them with a soft cloth after wearing to remove any oils or sweat. Natural body oils and perspiration can gradually erode the nacre if left on the pearls.
    • Store them separately from other jewelry to avoid scratches. Pearls are relatively soft compared to other gemstones and can be easily scratched. Consider keeping them in a soft pouch or lined jewelry box.
    • Avoid exposing them to perfumes, hairsprays, or other chemicals. These substances can dull the luster of pearls and potentially cause long-term damage.
    • Have them restrung every few years if you wear them often. The silk or nylon thread used to string pearls can weaken over time, especially with frequent wear.
    • Clean your pearls gently with a soft, damp cloth. Avoid using ultrasonic cleaners or harsh chemicals, as these can damage the nacre.
    • Store pearls in a cool, dry place. Extreme heat or dryness can cause pearls to crack or become brittle.
      Pistachio Pearl Hoop EarringsPistachio Pearl Hoop Earrings Detail

      Our Pistachio Pearl Hoop Earrings are a great example of how unique and beautiful real pearls can be. With proper care, these earrings will maintain their luster for years to come. The unique color of these pearls showcases the variety available in freshwater pearls and demonstrates how pearls can be both classic and contemporary in jewelry design.

      When to Seek Professional Help

      While these tips can help you spot real pearls in many cases, sometimes it's best to get a professional opinion. Consider consulting a jeweler or gemologist if:

      • You're thinking of buying an expensive pearl piece. A professional can verify the authenticity and assess the quality and value of high-end pearl jewelry.
      • You've inherited pearls and want to know their value. Antique or heirloom pearls may have historical or sentimental value in addition to their material worth.
      • You're unsure about the results of your own tests. If you're still in doubt after performing the basic tests, a professional can provide a definitive answer.
      • You're dealing with very rare or antique pearls. Unusual pearls or those with potential historical significance should be evaluated by an expert.
      • You need an official appraisal for insurance purposes. A professional appraisal is often required for insuring valuable pearl jewelry.
      • You're considering selling a pearl piece. An expert evaluation can help you determine a fair market value for your pearls.

      Experts have special tools and knowledge that can give you a definitive answer about your pearls' authenticity. They can use advanced techniques like X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy or Raman spectroscopy to analyze the chemical composition and structure of pearls, providing conclusive evidence of their origin and quality.

      Enchanting Tahitian Pearl DropsEnchanting Tahitian Pearl Drops Detail

      Our Enchanting Tahitian Pearl Drops are a perfect example of rare, high-quality pearls that have been authenticated by experts. These earrings showcase the unique colors and luster of Tahitian pearls, which are among the most valuable and sought-after pearls in the world.

      Conclusion: Embracing the Beauty of Real Pearls

      Learning how to tell if pearls are real can be fun and rewarding. Whether you're shopping for a special piece of jewelry or curious about a family heirloom, these tips can help you appreciate the unique beauty of genuine pearls. Understanding the characteristics of real pearls not only helps in identifying them but also deepens your appreciation for these natural wonders.

      Remember, real pearls are natural gems, each one slightly different and special in its own way. Their imperfections and variations are part of what makes them so beautiful and valuable. The subtle differences in color, shape, and surface texture tell the story of each pearl's formation, making every piece truly one-of-a-kind.

      If you're looking to add some authentic pearl jewelry to your collection, be sure to check out our pearl collection at Onabeam. We offer a range of beautiful, genuine pearl pieces that have been carefully selected for their quality and beauty. From classic strands to modern designs, our collection showcases the versatility and timeless elegance of real pearls.

      Elegant Pearl Charm NecklaceElegant Pearl Charm Necklace Detail

      Our Elegant Pearl Charm Necklace is a perfect example of how real pearls can be both classic and modern. It's a piece that showcases the timeless beauty of authentic pearls while incorporating contemporary design elements. This necklace demonstrates how pearls can be versatile and suitable for both everyday wear and special occasions.

      With these tips and a bit of practice, you'll be spotting real pearls like a pro in no time. Remember that while these methods can give you a good indication of a pearl's authenticity, professional appraisal is always recommended for valuable or significant pieces. Whether you're a pearl enthusiast or just beginning to explore the world of these oceanic gems, understanding and appreciating real pearls can enhance your jewelry experience and help you make informed decisions. Happy pearl hunting!

      FAQ

      What is the vinegar test for pearls?

      One of the easiest tests to help you identify real pearls from fake ones is the vinegar test. When you apply vinegar to pearls, if they feel gritty or glassy, they are probably fake. Real pearls tend to glide smoothly and reflect light beautifully, while faux pearls often show blemish or irregularity.

      This simple method can tell the real quality of natural or cultured pearls, as quality pearls have a perfectly round pearl shape and pearls closely resemble one another. However, it’s sometimes difficult to tell if they are natural and cultured pearls, especially when pearls are strung tightly in a strand of real jewelry.

      Additionally, pearls may feel rough around the drill holes, which can indicate authenticity. So, if you notice any signs of blemish or irregularity, your pearls may be probably fake and due for further inspection.

      Do real pearls sink or float?

      When considering if real pearls sink or float, it’s worth noting that pearls tend to be heavier than glass or plastic options. Whether cultured or natural, pearls have a smooth surface that can reflect light beautifully. If you rub one pearl against another, the texture should feel smooth or glassy.

      To conduct a foolproof test, you can drop a pearl strung necklace into salt water. If it sinks, it’s likely genuine; if it floats, you might be dealing with made from plastic or made from glass alternatives. Remember, if it seems too good to be true, it probably is.

      Real pearls often have slight imperfections, unlike their glass or plastic counterparts, which are typically flawless. So, when evaluating your jewelry, check the edge of your front to ensure authenticity. 

      How can you tell if a pearl is real at home? What is the pearl bite test?

      To determine if a pearl is real at home, first, examine how the pearls reflect light. Authentic pearls have a soft, shimmering glow, while fakes tend to shine too brightly. Next, check for any imperfections, as real pearls due to their organic nature often have minor flaws.

      Finally, try the tooth test: gently rub the pearl against your teeth. Real pearls feel gritty, whereas fake ones are smooth.

      How can you tell if a pearl is real with a lighter?

      To determine if a pearl is real using a lighter, gently heat it. Real pearls will not be affected, while fake ones made of plastic may melt. 

      How can you tell if pearls are real or cultured?

      To determine if pearls are real or cultured, examine their surface for imperfections; natural pearls typically have more irregularities. Additionally, you can conduct a tooth test: rubbing them against your teeth should feel gritty if they're real. Finally, check the drill hole; cultured pearls have smoother, more polished holes.

      Back to blog